Like Techgeist? Donate.
Need to Contact Us? Read This. Also, find out more about us on the About page.
Advertisement
Advertisement

Amazon Pulls Books From Users’ Kindles

By Michael Klurfeld on July 17, 2009
Courtesy: BlogKindle

Courtesy: BlogKindle

In a move of sheer irony, Amazon pulled digital copies of 1984 or Animal Farm right from the Kindles of paying customers. Apparently the publisher decided it no longer wanted to offer e-book versions of the novels. And somehow, the publisher, Signet Classics, was able to exert so much pressure on Amazon that they not only pulled it from the store, but deleted it off users’ devices.

Shame on Amazon for this, and I mean that very strongly. If you sell someone something, you can’t decide later on that you didn’t mean it. Signet Classics are a bunch of crazy people for not wanting digital versions of the books, but I thought Amazon was a good company. If Signet didn’t want to sell the products anymore, that’s fine, but don’t screw with the people who had already paid good money for it. Amazon should be standing up for the little guy. To my knowledge, customers got their money back, but this still stinks to high heaven.

Of course, this is indicative of the whole problem that we have with digital media and software. We no longer own the things we buy. Rather, we have the rights to use them. That’s why distributing those MP3s that you bought is illegal. They’re not yours to distribute. But it would be very nice if the people who sell us the rights don’t change their minds about what that means. We do have a capitalist system, which means that we are free to go buy from the people who don’t pull this kind of bullshit. That’s why may of us bought MP3s from the Amazon store instead of iTunes. But now that Amazon has fallen prey to some backwards rights holders, I’m not sure if I even feel comfortable doing that anymore.

(Original story via Pogue’s Posts)

Share
You can comment either manually filling in your personal information, or you can use your Facebook Account to fill in the information for you. Just click the button below to sign into Facebook.
Have Nothing To Say? Share this article with your friends using one of our share buttons above.

Leave a Comment.

Comments

  1. Why does anybody buy that thing? It’s poorly designed, difficult to use, slow, and uses DRM.

    Something like this is a much better choice: http://www.bookeen.com/ebook/ebook-reading-device.aspx

  2. Somewhere in there, I think I hear you saying that we should all go back to buying CDs again. That honestly wouldn’t bother me one bit.

    Anyway, this is a terrible move on Amazon’s part. I am extremely disappointed to hear this, but it makes me glad I don’t own a Kindle. George Orwell’s work is right at the top of my list of favorite literature, and I would have been seriously upset if I bought those books and they got pulled from my device.

    I wonder two things:
    1) Is there anywhere in the Kindle/Amazon user agreement that warns customers this might happen?
    2) Did they just pull 1984 and Animal Farm, or are all of Orwell’s works affected?

    • I didn’t see anything about any other books affected by this.

      What really gets to me is that it may be within Amazon’s legal rights, but that doesn’t mean we’re going to think highly of them for doing it. There are a lot of states in which it’s within you’re rights to shoot someone on your property with impunity, but I generally think asking questions before shooting is the way to go.

      I’ve been thinking a lot about this since I wrote the piece, and I think I’m going to have a followup tomorrow.

  3. [...] Amazon deleted copies of 1984 off of users’ Kindles, it made me pretty upset, to the point of writing up a proposal for [...]

  4. [...] all the hubub over Amazon’s pulling books from users’ Kindles (and George Orwell books, at that), Amazon has decided to do the right thing: it will be giving the [...]

Leave a Reply