“One Strike” Law Coming to the UK?
Apparently the incredibly strong reaction against an EU-wide three strikes law left no dent on some British organizations. Groups such as the British Phonographic Industry and the Federation Against Copyright Theft are lobbying Parliament to include provisions in the Digital Britain manifesto which would “force ISPs into banning users caught sharing illegally.” Any law which forces service providers to do this and all the data that watchdog groups claim they have are now and have always been completely bogus.
Let’s start with how wrong the data is. The first stat, that 50% of online traffic in the UK is illegal content, could be correct, but to say that file sharing is going to destroy DVD sales is plain wrong. If Joe Smith wants to own a DVD, he’s going to go and buy it. If Joe Smith instead, however, just has some small interest in seeing some movie once, why would anyone think he’d go out and buy it? If he’s so inclined, he might download it through illegal means, but there is nothing to suggest that every illegal download translates to a direct hit to sales. There’s another story …